jeremiahs Catering

Full-Service Catering for the Rochester, NY Area

Whether you're planning a small family reunion or a big corporate event, Jeremiah's Tavern® has you covered! Our special party package deals offer something for everyone on your guest list. And because we charge a fixed, per-person rate, you never have to worry about going over budget. We can also handle as much or as little of the actual service as you require. Here's how we do it...

We have been voted Best Neighborhood Bar and Best Sports Bar in the area, but not just because we offer a wide selection of 40 draft beers and a diverse menu comprised mainly of dishes and ingredients made in-house. We are a local favorite because we not only serve our community delicious food, beverage, and fun times, but we really serve our communities. Our catering services are an extension of our dedication and commitment to our neighbors in the Rochester region. We want to play a part in your happiest moments and celebrations.

Don't just take our word for it! See what others are saying about our catering service and read our testimonial below. For delicious, customized catering, Rochester, NY and surrounding area residents can view and print our specialized menu below. To have Jeremiah's Tavern® at your next event, call (585) 955-9559.

As Easy as 1 - 2 - 3

Choose Your Catering Style

Party Packages

(drop off & pick up)
Call for Pricing: (585) 955-9559

Tavern Wraps

2 Wraps: $16.50
3 Wraps: $19.00
each wrap comes with mac salad & house made potato chips

Russian Mistress

- Turkey, Tomato, Bacon, Spinach, Swiss

- Russian Dressing

- Rolled in a White Flour Tortilla

Turkey Cheddar BLT Wrap

- Turkey, Bacon Cheddar, Lettuce, Tomato

- Chipotle Mayo

- Rolled in a White Flour Tortilla

Apple Pecan Wrap

- Chicken, Apples, Pecans, Lettuce, Tomato

- Seasoned Mayo

- Rolled in a Garlic Herb Wrap

Kenny Wrap

- Broccoli, Artichokes, Roasted Peppers, Feta, Romaine Lettuce

- Tossed in Olive Oil

- Rolled in a Garlic Herb Wrap

The "1104" Buffet

Per Person: $14.99
Guests can build "1104 Plates"

- Zwiegles Hot Dogs

- Fresh Grilled Burgers

Sides Included: Macaroni Salad, Steak Fries, Meat Hot Sauce & Diced Onions
All the Fixins to build your own plates! (Includes Rolls)


Two Meats: $18.99
Three Meat: $20.99
(pricing is per person)

- Boneless breaded & sauced Chicken Wings - perfect size

- Award-Winning Chicken Wings

- Smoked Chicken Wings

- Pulled Pork Sliders

- Limit to 2 sauces

Sides Included: Mac Salad, Salt Potatoes & Jalapeno Cornbread

All-American Cook Out

Two Meats: $16.99
Three Meat: $18.99
(pricing is per person)

- Zweigles Hot Dogs

- Hamburgers

- Italian or Cajun Chicken Breast

- Italian Sausage

Sides Included: Macaroni Salad, House Made Potato Chips & House Salad (served with Ranch & Italian dressing) (Includes Rolls)

Texas BBQ Buffet

Per Person: $15.99

- BBQ Smoked Chicken Quarters and hickory smoked Pulled Pork with Mac Salad, Coleslaw, and Jalapeno Cornbread - (Includes Rolls)

Create your Own Buffet

(in house only)
Call for Pricing: (585) 955-9559

Option 1

Two Meats, Three Sides, Garden Salad, Rolls & Butter, and Soda & Coffee


Option 2

Three Meats, Three Sides, Garden Salad, Rolls & Butter, and Soda & Coffee


Meat Options


**Any In-House Package will include tax & a 15% gratuity charge**

Appetizer Menu

(in house, drop off & pick up)
Customize your party with any of the selections below. Menus are based on pre-arranged guest count and are not intended to be all-you-can-eat.
Call for Pricing: (585) 955-9559

Chicken Wings (50ct - $78.99) or Boneless Wings (50ct - $69.99)

Limit of 2 sauces: Mild, Medium, Hot, Catatonic, Wise Guy, Holy Habanero, Pow-Pow, Flyin' Hawaiian, Sweet & Sour, Tavern BBQ, Nawlins' Blues, Bee Sting, Cajun, & Garlic Parm.

Thin Crust Artisan Pizza's

Cut into 8 pieces - $13.50

The Standby

Jerry's sauce, Pepperoni, & Mozzarella Cheese

The BeeSting

Pulled Pork, beesting sauce, chedddar-jack cheese

Bruschetta Flat

Fresh Chopped Tomatoes, Garlic, Olive Oil, Mozzarella & Romano Cheese

BBQ Chicken

Tavern BBQ Sauce, Chicken Breast, Sauteed Onions, bacon, & Mozzarella Cheese

By the Pan...

Call for Pricing: (585) 955-9559

half pan

feeds 10-15 people

full pan

feeds 25-30 people


Jeremiah’s Catering did an exceptional job catering The Mackenzie Childs Barn Sale! Catering an event of 500 people is no easy task but Jeremiah’s did it beautifully. Everything from the Chicken French to the Pulled Pork exceeded our expectations. Our employees raved about the food. Easily the best caterer we have had at the event.

- John Vail | VP Finance/Operations

Mackenzie Childs Logo - Catering Testimonial Image

Questions about our catering services?

Please contact us at (585) 955-9559 today and feel free to stop by any of our locations.